Dosu Logo
Ask
DocumentsMag Stacker
e2e-dotenv-mise-clobbers-launcher-env
e2e-dotenv-mise-clobbers-launcher-env
Type
External
Status
Published
Created
Jul 4, 2026
Updated
Jul 4, 2026
Source
View

Playwright e2e all land on /login locally — a dev .env clobbers the Testcontainers run env#

Problem#

The Testcontainers-backed Playwright suite passed in CI but every spec failed locally, each landing on the login page. The webServer launcher (e2e/start-test-server.ts) resolves a per-run DATABASE_URL (the Testcontainers Postgres), BETTER_AUTH_URL (a reserved free port), and a random BETTER_AUTH_SECRET, then started next start as a spawned subprocess. That subprocess re-read the developer's local .env values (dev DB, dev origin) instead of the launcher's per-run env. Sessions are minted in-process against the container DB with the run's secret, so the app — reading the dev DB with the dev secret — rejected every session cookie and redirected to /login.

Symptoms#

  • Every spec — even ones unrelated to the change and previously passing (theme, auth, onboarding) — times out (e.g. getByRole("button", { name: "Add your first firearm" }) never resolves); the captured page snapshot is the "Sign in to your inventory" screen.
  • bun run test:e2e fails locally; the same suite is green in CI.
  • .env is gitignored, so CI has none — this is the local/CI split.

What Didn't Work#

  • Hiding .env for the run (rename before the app spawns, restore on exit): the app still read :3100/:5544, which proved the .env file was not the live source — mise (env_cache = true, _.file = ['.env', ...]) caches and re-injects those values. It was also fragile: Playwright hard-kills the webServer (SIGKILL), which skipped the restore and left .env renamed.
  • bun run --no-env-file start: no effect — Next's own @next/env loads .env independently of bun, so bun opting out doesn't stop it.
  • Trusting spawn(..., { env: process.env }): the launcher's process.env is correct at spawn time (verified by instrumentation), but bun/Next/mise re-apply the dev env inside the child before any app module reads it.
  • A start-app.ts argv shim (an earlier fix that worked but was replaced): a wrapper the launcher spawned instead of next start, which forced the three vars from process.argv before import("next/dist/bin/next"). It passed all specs, but it leaked the secret onto the command line, reconstructed process.argv, and imported an internal bin — a workaround for a subprocess that should not have existed. Superseded by serving Next in-process (below).

Solution#

Serve Next in-process from the launcher via its programmatic API instead of spawning a next start subprocess. The launcher already sets the run's env in process.env, and with no child process there is nothing to re-load .env/mise and clobber it (@next/env only fills unset vars, so the launcher's values survive):

// e2e/start-test-server.ts
import { nextStart } from "next/dist/cli/next-start";

// … container up, migrated, seeded, sessions minted, app built:
await nextStart({ port: PORT, hostname: "localhost" });

nextStart resolves once the server is listening; the open socket keeps the launcher process alive, and its existing SIGINT/SIGTERM trap stops the container on teardown (Ryuk reaps as a backstop). This is the production-server analog of the next/dist/cli/next-dev nextDev() pattern used by community Testcontainers + Next.js e2e templates. Result: all 13 e2e specs pass locally; CI (no .env) is unaffected.

Why This Works#

The env-clobbering only happened because a child process re-acquired the dev env (via bun's .env auto-load, Next's @next/env, or mise's env_cache) after inheriting the launcher's correct env. Running Next in the launcher's own process removes that seam entirely: there is no exec that re-triggers .env/mise loading, and @next/env, which preserves keys already present in process.env, keeps the launcher's DATABASE_URL/BETTER_AUTH_URL/BETTER_AUTH_SECRET. The secret matters as much as the DB: sessions are minted with the launcher's random BETTER_AUTH_SECRET, so the server must validate the cookie HMAC with that same secret — the dev secret would reject the cookie even against the right DB.

Prevention#

  • In Testcontainers / ephemeral-env harnesses, don't spawn the app as a subprocess and rely on env inheritance — bun and Next both auto-load .env, and mise env_cache re-injects it. Start the app in-process (Next's nextStart/nextDev), or make the whole e2e config static (dedicated .env.e2e + fixed ports, the template approach) so there is nothing dynamic to inject.
  • Remember the CI/local gap: .env is gitignored, so a harness that is green in CI can still be broken locally. Reproduce locally with a dev .env present; instrument the actual read site (getSession, DB client) to see the runtime env, not the launcher's.
  • Secondary spec-authoring gotchas surfaced here: required fields render their label as "Name *" (asterisk <span>), so once a sibling "Nickname" field exists, match with getByLabel(/^Name/) — exact "Name" matches neither "Name *" nor "Nickname"; and use .first() on completion toasts when a spec creates several records in a row, since the toasts stack and a bare getByText("Firearm logged") resolves to multiple elements.
  • Surfaced while adding the firearm nickname feature (#18) and its e2e spec.
  • AGENTS.md documents the adjacent mise sticky-env gotcha (env_cache=true, default :3000 / full-setup :3100 origin) and warns that BETTER_AUTH_URL must equal the request origin.
  • Reference pattern: varianter/testcontainers-nextjs-template (in-process nextDev, dedicated .env.e2e, fixed ports).